Building a brand around what you know is pretty awesome, right? Sharing your skills and experience can open doors to amazing things – think exposure, connections, cash flow, and that sweet feeling of accomplishment. It’s definitely worth going for!
But before you become a superstar online expert, there’s a key question: How will you share your knowledge with the world? That’s where choosing between online courses and membership sites comes in. Both can do wonders for you if you use them the right way. So, on that note, let’s take a deep dive and examine the differences and pros and cons of each model.
Disclaimer: The article may include affiliated links.
What Is an Online Course Platform?
Think of an online course platform as a two-part system that streamlines the process of building and running your course business.
The first part consists of the e-learning authoring tools. They allow you to develop and deliver your course content in engaging ways.
The learning management system (LMS) is the essential second part that powers your course. It handles the behind-the-scenes tasks like enrollment, student progress tracking, and even sales (depending on the platform).
These terms can be confusing, but don’t worry! Most modern course platforms have your back. They conveniently combine both functionalities so you can focus on what you do best – creating your course content without getting stuck in technical details.
The distinction between these elements usually comes into play for large institutions that create custom courses. For example, an instructional designer might use e-learning authoring tools to craft the content, while a separate course manager might handle the LMS aspects like sales and student support.
The good news for most online course creators? You likely wear both hats! The beauty of most course software is that it seamlessly integrates these functionalities, allowing you to focus on what matters most: building a fantastic course.
What Is a Membership Site?
Membership sites are essentially gated online spaces offering exclusive content to paying members. Typically, members join through monthly or annual subscriptions, gaining access to the valuable content within the site.
The content itself can vary depending on your business focus. It could include online courses, downloadable resources, live events, or even a dedicated community forum.
Running a membership site is a strategic move that offers advantages for both you (the creator) and your members. You benefit from recurring revenue streams, while members receive ongoing value each month. Membership sites are also powerful tools for fostering a loyal community around your expertise.
What Is the Difference Between a Membership Site and an Online Course?
Online courses have a clear beginning and end point. The student knows exactly what the curriculum is and how long it will take to finish all of the lessons. Membership sites don’t usually have an end date. They are designed to provide information on a regular basis as long as the student wants. In addition, more often than not, memberships include live events and online meetups that help you build a strong community of like-minded individuals. This way, your users receive both know-how and a supporting environment. Both strategies offer fantastic ways to share your knowledge and expertise but have their own specifics and requirements.
The Goal
The main difference between courses and membership sites is what you are trying to achieve.
Online Courses: Fast Track to Skills
Online courses are all about getting your students up to speed on a skill ASAP. It means:
- Breaking things down into bite-sized chunks
- Packing in tons of useful info
- Gearing them towards independent learning with homework assignments
The goal? Students learn the ropes with minimal hand-holding from you. Collaboration and community discussions might be included, but the focus is on solo learning.
Memberships: Building a Community
On the other hand, membership sites are all about keeping people engaged for the long haul. This predictable income stream is what makes memberships such a sweet business model. To keep members happy and paying their dues, you will focus on:
- Releasing exclusive content regularly (think a predictable schedule of fresh goodies)
- Hosting special events just for members
- Regularly interacting with your members to help them overcome challenges on their way to their goals
- Creating discussion boards where members can chat with each other
Basically, you will want to give your members reasons to keep paying that monthly fee and stay part of your awesome community.
How You Get Paid
Another big difference is how you make money.
Online Courses: One-Time Payment
Think of online courses like selling a digital toolbox. You give students access to all the videos and materials in one shot. They pay a one-time fee upfront (unless you offer installments) and get lifetime access to everything, including any updates you make down the road.
Since it is a one-time shot at getting paid, courses typically range from a few hundred bucks to a few thousand dollars. The price usually depends on how long the course is and what skills it teaches – the more complex, the steeper the price tag.
Memberships: Monthly Dues
Membership sites are more like subscription services. People pay a recurring fee to join your awesome community and receive a steady stream of fresh content. If they stop paying, they lose access.
Membership fees are typically more affordable because you are getting paid every month. According to a report by Membership Geeks, most business-to-consumer memberships cost between $25 and $49 a month. Interestingly, the report also found that expensive memberships (over $50) actually make less money overall than cheaper ones.
Time Investment
Both online courses and memberships take time, but the latter are a bit more high-maintenance.
Online Courses: You Do Work Only Once
With online courses, you only need to create your lessons once. Once the course is built and uploaded, you are pretty much set. You might update it occasionally and answer some student emails, but if you have automated your marketing, the online course can become a sweet, passive income machine.
Memberships: For the Long Run
Membership sites are more like a long-term commitment. In addition to building the site, you will need to constantly nurture the community by interacting with members and keeping them engaged with fresh content. Think of it like tending a garden – you need to water and nurture it to keep things blooming. The bright side is that membership sites provide a steady, recurring income, so you can easily plan your budget and relieve the stress of the unknown.
Content Creation
The amount of content you have to churn out is a big difference between courses and memberships.
Online Courses: One Big Project
Courses are all about creating one main piece of content: the course itself. It might involve chopping up videos into modules and throwing in some downloadable goodies like worksheets. But once it is done, you are good to go on the content creation front.
Memberships: The Content Never Sleeps
Membership sites, on the other hand, are content creation beasts! Remember that whole “keeping members engaged” thing from the first point? That means constantly coming up with fresh stuff to keep them happy. And it is not just about videos and articles – you might be cooking up all sorts of things, like ebooks, announcements, webinar content, templates, and even social media posts and email newsletters.
Where Your Content Lives
Another difference is where your content lives. Online courses are all stored on the platform you choose. You upload everything there, and your students can access it all in one spot. You can advertise your courses using multiple channels, but the content itself is contained in one place – a course platform, your website or an online course marketplace.
There are many more ways to distribute and share your membership content; it all depends on how your target audience prefers to receive your regular dose of content. Some software, like Kajabi, allows you to gather your users in one place, such as forums, live events, and podcasts. You can use one software to host your content and build your community in a Facebook group, Telegram channel, Viber group, etc. With membership sites, the choice of where your content lives is solely up to you and your business goals.
Tech Tools You Need
Both courses and memberships need some tech muscle to function:
- A microphone and video camera (or webcam) to record your incredible lessons – You can actually use your phone, as some smartphones have killer cameras.
- Video editing software to polish those recordings and make them shine – If you don’t have the funds to purchase a professional product, there is a lot of free software you can use.
- Audio recording software if you are including audio-only content.
- Screen-sharing software if you want to walk students through things on their computers.
- A landing page builder to create a cool signup page for your course.
- An online course platform – it is where students will access your course content.
You might also want a keyword research tool to help people find your course online. Once you have this tech toolbox, you are good to go!
Community
The biggest difference between online courses and memberships is the whole “community” thing.
Online Courses: Buy, Learn, Move On
Think of an online course as a product you sell – a one-time transaction. Students pay for access to your knowledge and know-how, and that is usually the end of the story. You then market to new students to keep the money flowing.
The tools used to create courses aren’t really built for fostering a community (if at all). If you are keen on building one alongside your course, you will have to do it on another platform, like a Facebook group. But even then, it won’t be as robust as what a membership site can offer.
Memberships: Building a Community Hub
Membership sites are all about community from the get-go. It is more like creating an ongoing experience. Since you want members to stick around, you will build a digital space they can call home for a long time. Your membership might offer cool perks like one-on-one video calls, private coaching sessions, or even virtual conferences.
You could even take things offline and organize meetups or international summits in amazing locations. Encouraging member-to-member interaction is key because people love connecting with others who share their interests. This way, your members benefit from your expertise and the experiences of their fellow members. It is a win-win.
Sponsors and Affiliates
Both online courses and memberships can attract sponsors, but memberships tend to be a sponsor magnet.
Why? Sponsors want to see a big, engaged audience before they open their wallets. With a membership site, people come back every month, making it easy to show sponsors that sweet, engaged community you have built.
Online courses, on the other hand, might be a tougher sell. Students are there to learn new skills, and paid shoutouts might not be their cup of tea. Plus, convincing sponsors to back a course before it is even created can be tricky.
Affiliates, on the other hand, work great with both online courses and membership sites. For example, you are fond of Canva and teach your students how to use it. You already shared the link to this product, so why not make it an affiliate? People tend to trust affiliates more since, with sponsored products, you get paid upfront to push something into your audience. With affiliates, everything is in your users’ hands.
Pros and Cons of Online Course and Membership Site
Both business models have strengths and weaknesses, and you need to consider them all when deciding. And what better way to do this than a side-by-side comparison?
| Online Course | Membership Site | |
|---|---|---|
| Pros | ✔ You do the bulk of the work only once.
✔ Passive income with minimal effort on your part ✔ Faster to create since they have a start and finish. ✔ Have a high-price potential ✔ Students understand from the start what they will get |
✔ Members stay engaged for longer periods, increasing their overall value to your business.
✔ A more cost-effective option for your members than a one-time course purchase. ✔ Creating a strong community ✔ Offer a secure, recurring income ✔ Membership sites allow you to release fresh content regularly, keeping your offerings dynamic and responsive to member feedback. ✔ You don’t have to create the whole content upfront. |
| Cons | ✖ Your income relies solely on individual sales.
✖ Course creators often experience fluctuating income. There can be surges during launch periods, followed by dips between launches. ✖ Without additional features like a community forum, students typically join your course, learn the material, and move on. This high turnover can make it difficult to foster interaction and build lasting connections with your student base. ✖ There is a high risk of content theft from your competitors. |
✖ Membership sites demand consistent effort and are not passive income streams.
✖ You need to come up with fresh, engaging content regularly. ✖ Membership sites typically offer a lower price point compared to online courses. ✖ Maintaining a low churn rate (the percentage of members who cancel their subscriptions) is an ongoing challenge for membership sites. The average churn rate is around 6-7% annually, meaning you will constantly be working to keep members engaged and prevent them from canceling. Compared to the one-time payment of online courses, the recurring revenue benefit of memberships hinges on your ability to retain customers over time. |
Which Model Is Best for Your Business?
You can start with either of the two business models. Both have strengths and weaknesses, and both are suitable for beginners.
So, how do you decide? Consider these three key questions:
- Predictable Income – Does your business model prioritize consistent revenue streams?
- Content Creation Commitment – Are you prepared to regularly create fresh content on your chosen topic?
- Building a Community – Do you envision fostering an online community around your offerings?
Still on the fence? Get valuable insights from your target audience. Conduct a survey to gauge their interest in online courses or memberships and the type of content they would find most appealing. This audience feedback can be the deciding factor in choosing the right model for you.
In conclusion
We have explored the distinct advantages of membership sites and online courses. Remember, focus on value, not deception. Customers expect a clear return on their investment. An online course disguised as a membership with minimal perks or community access won’t resonate with them. While a membership site with course content might be easier to sell initially, prioritize delivering an exceptional membership experience.
A strong course site can evolve into a membership site by consistently offering valuable content and exclusive benefits. Similarly, a membership site can add courses but ensure you have the systems in place to manage students effectively, track progress, and create high-quality course content.
The decision between online courses and membership sites goes beyond functionalities. It is about aligning your choice with your overall goals.